All-Time Wrestling Honors

NCAA DIVISION III ALL-AMERICAN

1989 - Rich Redfoot

NWCA SCHOLAR ALL-AMERICANS

1984 - Tim Valliere

1985 - Jeff Dixon

1986 - Larry Anker

1987 - Steve Castle

1988 - Lee Garlove

1992 - Peer Soderberg

1999 - Josh Chamberlain

2000 - Josh Chamberlain, John Sensing

2001 - Josh Chamberlain, Ezra Morse

2002 - Ezra Morse, Joe Mueller

2005 - Max Courtney

2006 - W&L received the team award and ranked 13th nationally in Team GPA

2007 - Kirk Adamson, Anthony Boniello, David Shubick. W&L also received the team award and ranked fourth nationally in Team GPA.

2008 -  Kirk Adamson, Anthony Boniello, Peter Lawrence, David Shubick.  W&L also received the team award and ranked 11th nationally in Team GPA.

2010 - Sam Campbell, David Dennis, Ben Ersing

2012 - Sam Campbell, David Dennis

ALL-CENTENNIAL CONFERENCE

2012 - David Dennis (Honorable Mention)